Perfect For Groups & Families!

The All-Star Ohio House

Downtown Put-in-Bay
Sleeps Up To 22 Adults
Direct TV
6 Full Bedrooms
3 Full Bathrooms
Linens Provided
Downtown Location!
2 Large Decks
Golf Cart Parking
Put-in-Bay Home Rental

Call (419) 320-8489

A Modern Rental Home In the Heart of Put-in-Bay!

The All-Star Ohio House is Put-in-Bay’s premier rental home located less than one block from the vibrant Put-in-Bay nightlife!

Often referred to as the Buckeye House, this century-old home was completely renovated & updated to honor the Ohio State Buckeyes and other notable Ohio Sports All-Stars!

Impeccably clean with modern attention to detail makes this Put-in-Bay Rental home the most sought-after location for groups, bachelor & bachelorette parties, family reunions, and other Put-in-Bay Events!!

Photo Of All Star Ohio House Put-in-Bay Living Room

Spacious Living Room

Enjoy your favorite sporting event on our 65′ TV or socialize with friends & family in our large TV/ Living Room!

Photo of All Star Ohio House Put-in-Bay Large Front Deck

Large Front Deck View

People watch & entertain your guests on one of Put-in-Bay’s Busiest Streets, just 200 feet from the main strip! 

Photo Of All Star Ohio House Put-in-Bay Back Deck

Spacious Back Deck & BBQ Area

Gather with friends & family for a game of cornhole or BBQ On your private & large rear deck!

All Star Ohio House Put-in-Bay Bedroom

Large Bedrooms

Large Bedrooms, many with two queen size beds and individually controlled AC Units

Photo Of All Star Ohio House Put-in-Bay Bathrooms

3 Large Bathrooms

Modern large bathrooms, 2 on the first floor and 1 on the second floor.

Photo Of All Star Ohio House Put-in-Bay Kitchen

Spacious Kitchen

Prepare meals in our well-equipped kitchen & BBQ Grill with friends on the back deck!

All Star Ohio House – Your Home Away From Home!

Accommodate Up To 22 Guests- All-Star Ohio House

Put-in-Bays Only Modern Downtown Rental Home!

The modern All Star Ohio House Put-in-Bay Rental Home features six bedrooms and three bathrooms with a large living room & social area, a modern, well-equipped kitchen, and TWO great private decks that are perfect for people-watching or enjoying the Put-in-Bay Vibe!

The All Star Ohio House front deck looks out over Loraine Ave, one of the busiest Put-in-Bay walking streets! Our rear deck opens to a large secluded private patio with cornhole, BBQ Grill, and picnic tables and is decorated with Ohio Sports Memorabilia. Be sure to Contact Us with ANY questions you may have!

Photo Of All Star Ohio House Put-in-Bay Back Social Area
Photo Of nightlife near All Star Ohio House

Put-in-Bay Rental Home…. Location Location Location!!!

Many Put-in-Bay Rental Homes are located in the center of the island, which is inconvenient, and are rustic homes. Our modern rental home eliminates the need for costly and time-consuming island transportation! The All-Star Ohio House has been voted one of the best places to stay on Lake Erie!

Once you’ve settled in your Put-in-Bay Home Rental, you’re less than 300 feet from the island’s best restaurants, nightlife, shopping, and the Put-in-Bay Waterfront.

The All-Star Ohio House allows you the convenience of being just a short walk from attractions and is less than one block from the famous Blue Marlin Pool Bar, the place to be and be seen at Put-in-Bay! Be sure to Visit Our FAQ page! To learn about Put-in-Bay, Click here!

Put-in-Bay Golf Cart Rentals

Once you’ve arrived at the All Star Ohio House, there is no better way to see the island than a Put-in-Bay Golf Cart Rental. Golf carts are rented by the hour, day, overnight, or several days at a time! You can reserve your 4-6 or 8-passenger golf cart online before you arrive! Reservations are strongly suggested, as there are a limited number of Golf Carts available for rent!

Many of the island’s attractions are beyond a comfortable walking distance, and a golf cart rental is an economical alternative to tired old taxi cabs that can be hard to find! Your golf cart rental allows you to come and go as you please and stay as long as you like at each venue!

The All-Star Ohio House recommends Put-in-Bay Golf Carts, the island’s largest and most modern fleet of late-model golf cart rentals. They’re located less than a block from your Put-in-Bay Rental Home, so pick-up and drop-off are a breeze!

Photo Of A Put-in-Bay Golf Cart Rental
Photo of Perry's Cave Put-in-Bay
Picture Of the Boardwalk Restaurant Put-in-Bay
Photo of the Cannons at Put-in-Bay
Put-in-Bay - A sunset view of the island.
Photo Of family fishing at Put-in-Bay
Picture of Mini Golf At Put-in-Bay
Photo Of Piratefest At Put-in-Bay
Picture Of the All Star Ohio House Put-in-Bay
Ariel Photo Of Put-in-Bay
Picture Of The Jet Express Put-in-Bay
Picture Of A Perch Dinner At Put-in-Bay
Picture of Food From The Boardwalk Put-in-Bay

Click on our helpful links below to learn about the many things to see & experience at Put-in-Bay!

The Put-in-Bay Visitors & Convention Bureau

offers visitors all the information needed to plan and enjoy a fabulous Put-in-Bay Vacation!

EXPLORE Put-in-Bay Attractions

Everything You Need To Know About Things To Do And Attractions To Experience On Your All Star Ohio House Vacation

EXPLORE Put-in-Bay Events

View Our Events Happening at Put-in-Bay South Bass Island in 2023!

LEARN ABOUT Put-in-Bay Restaurants

From Fast to Formal, Delivery to Waterfront! Everything You Need To Know About Dining!

EXPLORE! Put-in-Bay History

The History of Put-in-Bay Dates Back Over 150 Years! Learn About The Islands History!


What To See And Do On Your Ohio Vacation!

If you have visited Put-in-Bay, Ohio, before. If so, you’re likely still talking about your holiday getaway here and have some great memories! Over 800,000 visitors flock to Put-in-Bay annually to enjoy a Key West island-style vacation at one of the many popular Put-in-Bay Hotels.

Nothing on the United States north coast matches up to a West Shore Put-in-Bay Sunset or the sun rising from the waterline of Lake Erie! Take A stroll thru our quaint village streets where local proprietors display their wares, and the scents of freshly prepared chefs’ meals tempt your taste buds!

Our vibrant nightlife near the All Star Ohio House promotes audience participation with local musicians and nationally known acts. From the 150+-year-old Round House Bar to the World’s Longest Bar, the Beer Barrel Saloon, there is a music genre to suit everyone!

But if you’re fresh to the island, you’ll need some Put-in-Bay information from our helpful island guide! A favored pastime is touring the island on a 4-, 6- or 8-person golf cart available for rent from the Put-in-Bay Golf Carts, conveniently located downtown near the All Star Ohio House.

Put-in-Bay golf cart rentals are one of many ways to see the island! Bicycle & Moped rentals are also a fun way to get from location to location.

Plan for a beautiful sunset celebration while enjoying waterfront dining at a Put-in-Bay eatery! Watch the boaters in the historic downtown marina district. You’ll feel like you are genuinely in the Key West of the North! Think Jimmy Buffet Margaritaville!

It may seem a little overwhelming at first if you have never visited before, but boy, are you in for a real treat. Your Put-in-Bay Ferry from Port Clinton/Catawba to the island is an adventure all in itself! The principal methods of getting to and from the island are Miller Ferry Boat and the Jet Express just a block from the All Star Ohio House.

There is a Put-in-Bay attraction for everyone! Put-in-Bay is most noted for its history, but that’s not the only thing we’ve got going on.

We have some of the best freshwater fishing in the waters of Lake Erie! If you are an avid Walleye or Perch fisherman, you won’t be disappointed!

Enjoy some excitement while catching Walleye as they cross a beautiful flat sandy bottom along the Lake Erie islands shoreline. Think about making your fresh a catch seafood dinner at one of our local Put-in-Bay bistros. Enjoy a comfortable trip on a charter boat fishing or a rental kayak rental in the Put-in-Bay harbor.

Don’t miss exploring Perry’s Victory and International Peace Memorial, named after Commodore Oliver Hazard Perry! This historic site is worth visiting from anywhere in the United States, but local area travelers from Detroit, Cleveland, Sandusky, and Toledo can frequently see it from home on a clear day!

Put-in-Bay and the surrounding waters were at the forefront of the Battle of Lake Erie, which played a key part in the War of 1812. Local historical reenactments frequently occur on the monument’s grounds, presented by the Lake Erie Islands Historical Society.

If you’re arriving with the family and children, you’ll want to see some of the fun-filled, family-friendly island attractions on your Put-in-Bay time-out. This includes Perry’s Cave which is our official island family fun center.

Perry’s Cave has cave excursions, miniature golf, a butterfly house, a maze, rock climbing, an antique car museum, and more! We likewise suggest stopping by the South Bass Island Lighthouse, which can be found just past the Miller Ferry Island drop location.

The South Bass Island state park offers excellent camping, a playground, a pebble beach, and shoreline fishing. Jose DeRivera Park sits right in the core of the famous downtown area. The park is a remarkable testament to the island’s efforts to preserve its natural and historical beauty in the center of the town’s main commercial area.

Put-in-Bay attractions are so numerous that no matter what time of the year you come here, there is always something going on. The Put-in-Bay event schedule is loaded from early April to late October with unique festivals and events! Our annual Pirate Fest is one of our most well-known events, and we also get a huge crowd for the Halfway to St. Patrick’s Day celebration! We even have two special weekends to celebrate our customers, the Put-in-Bay Spring Fling and the Fall Ball hosted at the Put-in-Bay Resort! Book these early, as these weekends are island favorites!

Many vacation enthusiasts visit the island to hear and see the incredible Mike “Mad Dog” Adams show many weekends at the Roundhouse Bar.

Corporate groups can plan a fun and productive business meetings or company outings at the All-Star Ohio House!

Put-in-Bay Hotels

Info On Where to Stay At Put-in-Bay!

Put-in-Bay is enjoyable and can be as restful, romantic, or outlandish as you want it! There are accommodations in Put-in-Bay for every type of visitor. We have some of the most luxurious Put-in-Bay Villas, hotels, motels, Put-in-Bay resorts, and rental homes like the All Star Ohio House.

Many feature beautiful Carribean-themed landscaping and free-form pools with swim-up bars. We are one of Ohio’s best locations for Bachelor and Bachelorette Parties. You may find it challenging to think you are really in Ohio. That’s why this is the preferred vacation destination in the Midwest!

No matter where you select your lodging, always try to be located in town. Always the first to book, the downtown rentals eliminate the need to depend on taxi’s to get back and forth, which can be quite expensive. Check out the best Put-in-Bay Hotel Deals for your Ohio Vacation.

Put-in-Bay Boating and Marinas
It is hard to think that someone could observe the sunset on the beautiful, serene waters surrounding Put-in-Bay without enjoying getting closer! Take a ride to one of our neighboring islands Kelleys Island or Middle Bass Island. There are local ferry services that transport Put-in-Bay visitors back and forth for day trips!

The waters around Put-in-Bay are beautiful. Try charter boat fishing with our knowledgeable local Captains on the waters of Lake Erie or an afternoon Jet Ski ride. You can personally charter a craft, join a group, plan a sunset boat ride, or sign on with a large group! The romance and adventure of the islands are here for the taking, and lakeside sunsets are free for viewing. Stick around on a Sunday, and you can even see the antique car parade in the afternoon pass right by the boaters at the boat docks

Places to Eat & Drink in Put-in-Bay

Without a doubt, our two-by-four-mile island sure has a lot going on with food and beverage options. The last count was over 50 drinking and eating options, with more popping up yearly! One thing you can be sure of while visiting Put-in-Bay is local fresh seafood! Dining outside and on the waterfront is a favorite because those restaurants have a view and are located just a short walk from the All Star Ohio House.

Some have a stunning view of the sundown, and others have a view of the Put in Bay marina and downtown area. There are multiple restaurants off the beaten path. Ask the locals where to eat; everyone has a favorite place here or a place they would love you to go try. Plenty of bars and great entertainment are yours to enjoy at Put-in-Bay. Take a walk toward The Boardwalk and find one that suits you and enjoy the surroundings. Some bars have local bands and music almost all day and night, and others have a calm and quiet atmosphere with a tranquil view of the Put-in-Bay waterfront.

Ready to start your vacation to Put-In-Bay?

The sooner you book at the All Star Ohio House, the sooner you can get on a Put-in-Bay ferry! So what are you waiting for?

Put-in-Bay is full of attractions and fun things to do besides the bars! You can tour the South Bass Island Lighthouse, visit Perry’s Cave Family Fun Center for mini-golf, or take a narrated tour of the Butterfly House. For those seeking adventure, rent a kayak, Parasail, or zip around on a Jet Ski!

Have a family picnic at the South Bass Island State Park, which has shady picnic areas and lakefront views. Put-in-Bay, Ohio, is home to the Put-in-Bay Resort, Edgewater Hotel, and Bay Lodging Resort. Lakeview resort hotels with outdoor swim-up pool bars can be seen on the island. Poolside tiki bars such as the Award Winning Blue Marlin bar can be found within walking distance of the All Star Ohio House Home Rental.

All Star Ohio House

Guest Reviews

We have stayed at the All Star Ohio House for the last three years, and it’s our “go-to” place at Put-in-Bay. The location can’t be beaten, and we love not having to drag linens and bedding over as other rentals require. Always clean and comfortable!

Dominica Simpson

All Star Ohio House What a GREAT place! It was so convenient to be this close to the restaurants and bars! We were able to walk pretty much everywhere and were not waiting for taxi cabs all the time. The front porch was really cool to watch some of the Put-in-Bay people! The owners were really nice and there at check in and check-out. We will be back! GO BUCS!

David Thorton

We had our family reunion at the All Star Ohio house summer of 2022 and were pleased with the location and cleanliness. The back deck area is huge and was perfect for a BBQ, and they provided cornhole boards. At night it was quiet, but we knew less than a book away was some great nightlife!

Brandy Zimmer

We have been regulars to Put-in-Bay for many years, and this year, our family decided to book the All Star Oho House instead of staying outside of town. It was a GREAT choice! Clean and well-furnished, we saved money cooking several of our meals in the well-stocked kitchen and using their BBQ Grill. Nice addition to the downtown area!

The Brown Family

All star Ohio House

Amenities, Services, & Features

Free WiFi
Free Parking For 2 Cars
6 Bedroom Comfort
3 Full Bathrooms
Large Family / Social Room
Pool / Swim Up Bar Access
Full Size Modern Kitchen
BBQ Grill & Cornhole Boards
2 Large Deck Areas
Put-in-Bay Golf Cart Rental Info

At Put-in-Bay, We use golf carts to get around the island.We suggest main a reservation in advance! You may click here to make a Put-in-Bay Golf Car Reservation!

Put-in-Bay Taxi Info

Put-in-Bay is served by Coops Cabs with late model clean and airconditioned taxis. Advance reservations may be made for pick up. Put-in-Bay Taxi Service

Visit Put-in-Bay In Style!

Check To See If We Have A Vacancy!

Just click the tab to the right to submit a reservation request for your desired dates! A representative will contact you to confirm rates & availability.

394 Loraine Avenue Put-in-Bay Ohio 43456

Contact Us